Rob Blake of the Los Angeles Kings is being criticized for trades that may have sacrificed long-term prospects for short-term gains.
Despite his respect in the league, Bill Guerin is faulted for the Minnesota Wild's inability to advance in the playoffs under his tenure.
Don Waddell of the Columbus Blue Jackets is scrutinized for organizational instability and questionable roster decisions.
Steve Yzerman's rebuilding efforts with the Detroit Red Wings have shown promise but have yet to translate into playoff success, with goaltending decisions and roster adjustments drawing particular scrutiny.
Brad Treliving, now with the Toronto Maple Leafs, is judged on his previous tenure with the Calgary Flames, where strong regular seasons failed to yield deep playoff runs.
Each GM faces unique challenges and expectations as they navigate the complexities of NHL management and strive to meet the demands of their respective fanbases and organizations.
Source: The Hockey Writers
NHL's 5 Most Overrated General Managers
POLL | ||
Do you think Steve Yzerman deserves his place on this list? | ||
Yes | 40 | 65.6 % |
No | 21 | 34.4 % |
List of polls |