While re-signing Patrick Kane is a highlight, adding Vladimir Tarasenko to replace David Perron provides a younger, still impactful offensive presence. However, the defensive changes are less impressive.
The departure of Jake Walman, a key shot-blocking defenseman, leaves a notable gap. Simon Edvinsson's potential is promising, but his adaptation to the NHL remains uncertain. Pairing Edvinsson with Jeff Petry might work, but relying on Ben Chiarot as a top-pairing defenseman with Moritz Seider is concerning due to Chiarot's inconsistency.
The third pairing lacks clear strength, with options like Olli Maatta, Albert Johansson, Erik Gustafsson, and Justin Holl providing depth but no significant upgrade. This lack of impactful talent suggests a lateral move rather than a step forward.
In goal, replacing James Reimer with Cam Talbot is seen as an upgrade. Talbot's experience is promising, but Detroit's defensive struggles could impact his performance. Pairing Talbot with Alex Lyon and possibly Ville Husso while waiting for Sebastian Cossa to develop is sensible but conservative.
To truly progress, the Red Wings need more impactful defensive additions to avoid similar challenges in the upcoming season.
Source: Octopus Thrower
Yzerman still has work to do if the Red Wings hope to take a step forward in 2024-25
POLL | ||
Do you think Steve Yzerman needs to improve his defense to complete his rebuild? | ||
Yes | 39 | 97.5 % |
No | 1 | 2.5 % |
List of polls |